BitCoin: Consensus without Identity – The Block Chain Revolution

Consensus algorithms are typically built on the premise that nodes in a network have identities. However, BitCoin, the groundbreaking cryptocurrency, challenges this notion by operating without the need for node identities. In this article, we will explore why BitCoin nodes don’t have identities, how consensus is achieved without them, and the role of proof-of-work in maintaining the integrity of the BitCoin network.

Why Don’t BitCoin Nodes Have Identities?

In a decentralized peer-to-peer network like BitCoin, nodes lack the authority to create new node identities. Additionally, without a central authority to verify identities, it becomes impossible to prevent malicious actors from creating multiple identities to manipulate the system—a type of attack known as a Sybil attack.

Another reason for avoiding identities in BitCoin is privacy. The cryptocurrency is built around the concept of pseudonymity, allowing users to transact without revealing their true identities. Introducing node identities would compromise this core principle.

Implicit Consensus: Reaching Consensus Without Identities

In the absence of identities, BitCoin employs a different approach to achieve consensus. Randomly selected nodes take turns proposing transaction blocks to the network, indicating which transactions should be recorded next in the blockchain. Other nodes in the network approve or disapprove of the proposed block by either adding it to their own blockchains or omitting it and moving on to the next proposed block.

The blockchain’s structure facilitates this consensus process. Each block contains a hash of the previous block, allowing nodes to reference and extend the blockchain while maintaining a chronological order of transactions.

The BitCoin Consensus Algorithm

To understand the BitCoin consensus algorithm, let’s examine the step-by-step process:

  1. New transactions are broadcasted to all nodes in the network.
  2. Each node continuously listens to the network and collects new transactions into a block.
  3. In each round of proposal, a randomly chosen node broadcasts its block of outstanding transactions to the network.
  4. Other nodes only accept the block if all transactions within it are valid. Valid transactions must have valid digital signatures and unspent coins.
  5. If accepted, nodes include a hash of this newest block in their next block.
  6. If rejected, nodes omit the block and use the hash of the most recent valid block instead.

As a transaction receives more confirmations (each time it is recorded in the blockchain), the probability of a double-spending attack decreases exponentially. A general rule of thumb is to wait for six confirmations to have a high degree of confidence in the transaction’s validity.

Incentives and Proof of Work

Assuming the honesty of nodes in their transactions is problematic, as there is potential for bad actors to manipulate the system for personal gain. To promote honest behavior, BitCoin introduces incentives. These incentives consist of two mechanisms:

  1. Block reward: The creator of a block includes a special transaction in the block, known as a coin-creation transaction, which rewards the node for proposing the block. This block reward decreases over time and is halved approximately every four years. Eventually, the total number of BitCoins in circulation will be capped at 21 million, making it a finite resource.
  2. Transaction fees: Transaction creators have the option to include a transaction fee with their transaction. This fee is a voluntary payment made to the node that confirms the transaction by including it in a block. As the block reward diminishes, transaction fees will likely increase in importance and become mandatory for incentivizing miners.

Proof of Work: Ensuring Security and Preventing Monopolies

BitCoin tackles the challenges of random node selection and the prevention of node monopolies through the concept of proof of work. Instead of relying on identities, BitCoin selects nodes based on computational resources that no single entity can monopolize—specifically, computing power.

The proof-of-work system employed by BitCoin is known as hash puzzles. When a node proposes a block, it must include a nonce (a random number) along with the block’s payload. The nonce, previous block link, and list of transactions are combined into a long string, which is then hashed. To be considered valid, the hash output must be a very small number that fits within a predefined target space—a fraction of the total output space of the hash.

Finding a valid nonce is computationally difficult and requires significant processing power. Nodes compete with each other to solve these hash puzzles, with the successful miner gaining the right to propose the next block of transactions.

Properties of Proof of Work and Mining Economics

Proof of work in BitCoin exhibits several key properties:

  1. The hash puzzle must be computationally challenging to maintain network security.
  2. The difficulty of the hash puzzle is recalculated every two weeks to ensure an average block discovery time of approximately 10 minutes.
  3. The probability of solving a hash puzzle is directly proportional to the fraction of global hash power controlled by an individual miner.
  4. Verifying the correctness of a solved hash puzzle is straightforward, allowing miners to quickly validate each other’s work.

Regarding mining economics, the profitability of mining BitCoins depends on factors such as computing power, electricity costs, and the current value of BitCoin. As of now, mining BitCoins is not considered profitable for most individuals, unless they have access to significant computing resources and cost-effective electricity. However, market conditions can change, impacting the profitability of mining operations.


BitCoin has revolutionized the concept of consensus in the world of cryptocurrencies by eliminating the need for node identities. Through implicit consensus and the use of proof of work, BitCoin ensures the integrity and security of its blockchain network. By incentivizing miners through block rewards and transaction fees, the system promotes honest behavior. As we continue to witness the evolution of cryptocurrencies, understanding the underlying principles of consensus algorithms and their impact on network security will be crucial for shaping the future of decentralized finance.